Today’s BlogHer Book Club selection is Daring Greatly by Brene Brown. As usual, this is a paid review but the opinions are my own. For more, be sure to start here. The first discussion item is here.
Dr. Brown is a researcher in “shame and empathy.” The central idea of this book is that we all experience shame — a lot of shame, most of the time — and that our shame causes us to develop mostly unhealthy coping mechanisms that are meant reduce our perceived vulnerability to others, but in actuality cause us to not connect well with others. Rejecting this cycle, embracing our vulnerability, and developing “shame resilience” allows us to live “Wholehearted” lives (her capitalization, not mine). We can only do this by “daring greatly.” This last is a reference to one of Teddy Roosevelt’s speeches, which you can hear here.
So here’s the problem: in Dr. Brown’s eyes, I am either ludicrously well adjusted, or I am a sociopath. I don’t fear people laughing at me. I don’t spend all day worrying that my child will have an accident a school and I won’t have been there to stop it. I don’t feel guilty about not looking perfect at all times. Do I occasionally screw up and have to say to myself “Well that was dumb and I shouldn’t have done that”? Of course I do! But I don’t dwell on it and I don’t let fear or guilt control my life!
Dr. Brown tries very hard to write an accessible book: references to pop culture such as Harry Potter and Hotel California; pseudo-catchy phrases like Gremlin Ninja Warrior Training; admissions that she has been known to use colorful language. She does occasionally neglect to footnote when “research says”. She has done TED talks, seminars, written multiple books, talked to oodles of CEOs, and even given a lecture for Navy SEALs — and she will mention “examples” from any of the above as often as she can think to do so. Perhaps the researcher is too close to her subject matter and needs to work on self-esteem.
However, the book is not without merit. Dr. Brown is correct that love and connection is a basic human need. It’s useful to know that all most some men are driven by the fear that somebody will think they are “pussies.” All of us benefit from understanding that there are people out there who will use guilt to manipulate others, including bosses, significant others, and even teachers. The first time somebody thought to say “there are no stupid questions” was almost certainly in response to shame. There is a nice list of questions for gauging an office’s culture in chapter 5.
Dr. Brown is also the author of I Thought It Was Just Me. Well maybe it’s not just her, but it certainly isn’t me.
In Closing: math; disappearing; rivalry; human rights; Fred spread; predator; that’s why; long memories.
4×4 + 4×4 + 4 – 4×4 = ?
Systems? What about order of operations?
If you’ve ever wondered about the power of shame in your own and others’ lives, this is just the book for you. If you’ve even wondered how to counter all the shaming messages sent to you by the wider society, this is just the book for you.I was particularly attracted to Brown’s analysis of the role of shame in maintaining our cultural status quo; knowing exactly who benefits from your feeling inadequate. Who makes money if you don’t feel attractive enough, competent enough, patient enough…?Speaking as one with a huge respect for social research, I appreciated the careful, sustained inquiry into such a painful topic. And it’s not just valuable for women; she is careful to note (albeit towards the end) that shame is as large a topic in men’s lives as it is in women’s–the triggers are just different.Though scholarly, the language is not academic, which makes the material more accessible. An excellent first read to understand the subject of shame and it’s place in ALL our lives.